Health Care Lawyer Blog

The Detroit Free Press reported last night that a petition drive to give voters a chance to vote on "Universal Health Care" has fallen about 260,000 signatures short of the 390,000 needed to qualify for a ballot position. However, petition drive chairman John Freeman, recognizing that the ballot effort was abandoned because of lack of financial resources and competition from other ballot initiative drives, is reported to have shifted his focus to lobbying attempts.

The petitioners, in my opinion, are well-meaning, but a mandate to the Michigan legislature is doomed to failure. This body is too split by partisan bickering, carried on by inexperienced, term-limited synchophants, to reach a meaningful compromise on such a volatile subject as universal health care. Further, even if they could, the economy in Michigan would never be able to fund such efforts.

Ironically, placement of the petition on the ballot, I believe, would have led to passage where there are some 1.2 million--or more--uninsured Michiganders--and countless other under-insureds. Significantly, the health industry -- the growth engine of Michigan where 1 in 10 Michiganders work (more than twice those directly employed in the auto industry) according to Crain's Detroit Business-- should support a lobbying effort--if it realizes that such a program would mean a million or more new paying customers. Unfortunately, none of the plans on the table in conventional debates will solve the problems with present health insurance by improving health delivery structural deficiencies, the burden on employers and still provide choice to patients and discretion to physicians. I have highlighted a plan which meets all of these objectives in an earlier entry on this Blog--but I doubt it will be debated--it is too logical and efficient.

Nevertheless, the petition effort did keep the dialogue going. Let's hope someone is listening.